Soham Sinha MS, PhD, Dana B. Mukamel PhD, Debra Saliba MD, MPH, Heather Ladd MS, R. Tamara Konetzka PhD
Abstract
Objective
This study examines how measures of staffing—turnover and instability—are associated with one another and how they independently contribute to quality of care in nursing homes.
Design
Cross-sectional analysis of 2021–2022 administrative data. Data included the Payroll Based Journal for daily staffing information, merged with Nursing Home Care Compare (NHCC) data for nursing home characteristics, total staffing turnover, and nursing home quality.
Setting and Participants
A total of 11,840 nursing homes nationally reporting data on daily staffing and staffing turnover.
Methods
We explored correlations between measures of staffing and estimated facility-level regression models with robust standard errors. The dependent variables were indicators of nursing home quality included in the NHCC 5-star ratings. The independent variables of interest were average total staffing hours per resident-day, total staffing turnover, and total staffing instability.
Results
For the 11,840 nursing homes in the study, there was a weak positive correlation between turnover and instability, with some overlap between nursing homes with high instability and high turnover. Regression analysis revealed that staffing instability and turnover contributed independently to nursing home quality, with instability having a stronger association with some measures of quality and turnover with others. Staffing instability was positively and more strongly associated with long-stay residents' decline in activities of daily living levels and receipt of antipsychotic drugs and short-stay residents' functioning at discharge. Turnover was positively and more strongly associated with long-stay residents' prevalence of pressure ulcers and worsening mobility, and short-stay residents’ hospitalizations.
Conclusion and Implications
Instability and turnover in total nursing home staffing independently contribute to nursing home quality. This suggests that adding measures of staffing instability to the existing measures of average staffing and staff turnover in NHCC may enhance the report card's value for providers engaged in quality improvement and consumers searching for high-quality nursing homes.